The eatery, with its walls featuring photos of regular customers, some of whom have been coming to the restaurant since it opened in 1931, won with 36 percent of the vote. Go here to read more.
Luigi's in Ringwood came in second with 26 percent.
Patsy's will be awarded with a DVlicious certificate along with bragging rights to "slicing" the competition.
Next up for DVlicious: Wings, so put on your thinking caps, Passaic.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Paterson and receive free news updates.